Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Water Column Separation with Air Injection in a Francis Type Model Hydraulic Circuit

Abstract

During load rejections in hydraulic turbines and pumps, water column separation WCS may occur due to the pressure drop downstream of the guide vanes, leading to vapor cavity formation. The subsequent collapse of these cavities generates pressure surges that can cause runner upthrust and damage mechanical components. Mitigation strategies include reducing the guide vane closing rate and injecting air, the latter being preferred as it does not significantly increase the overspeed. To assess the effect of air injection, WCS tests were conducted in a Francis-type model-scale hydraulic circuit without runner. Results confirm that air injection effectively reduces pressure surges. They also show that both the maximum vapor volume and corresponding pressure surge, are proportional to the closing rate above a minimum threshold, while surge timing remains largely independent of the closing rate under fixed initial conditions. Based on this observation, a characteristic surge time is derived and compared with experimental data from various sources. A novel simulation approach based on one-way coupling between 1D simulation approaches and CFD is presented and validated against three separate measurement campaigns, including prototype measurements from a Francis turbine. Overall, the simulations show good agreement with the experimental data.

S Afara, ANDRITZ Hydro; B Nennemann, ANDRITZ Hydro; Hugo Mesnage, SuperGrid Institute; Fabien Grand-Perret, SuperGrid Institute

Presented at 33rd Symposium on Hydraulic Machinery and Systems, IAHR, Sep 2026, Foz do Iguaçu, Brazil.

To access the full text of this publication, click here.